The air in Westville, New Jersey, carries the scent of freshly baked bread and Italian meats. It is here, amidst the unassuming landscape of South Jersey, that Nicholas Papanier Jr. orchestrates a quiet revolution. He runs a sandwich empire, PrimoHoagies, a name that resonates with a growing legion of loyal customers across the East Coast and beyond. Papanier, a man whose lineage ties directly to the first PrimoHoagies shop, now leads one of the fastest-growing brands in fast-casual dining. He embodies a blend of fierce dedication, strategic foresight, and an unwavering commitment to his family’s legacy.
From Family Shop to National Presence: A Story of Growth
Nicholas Papanier Jr.’s journey began in the shop his family built. He learned the rhythm of the business from his father, absorbing the values and understanding the intricate operations that made PrimoHoagies special. He grew up smelling the provolone, watching the careful layering of ingredients, and hearing the laughter of customers. This immersive upbringing forged a deep connection to the brand, a bond that guides his decisions today.
He rose through the ranks with purpose. In 2017, he became Chief Operating Officer. Two years later, in 2019, he took the helm as Owner, President, and CEO. These were not mere title changes. Papanier assumed full responsibility for the company’s trajectory. He committed himself to preserving the quality and tradition that defined PrimoHoagies, even as he pushed for ambitious national expansion.
Under his command, PrimoHoagies has achieved remarkable milestones. Sales hit $94.6 million in 2024, a testament to his strategic prowess. The company opened its 125th store, a significant marker of its expanding footprint. Since 2020, PrimoHoagies has seen continuous year-over-year increases, a feat made more impressive considering the global challenges of that period. Papanier’s strategic expansion efforts have taken the brand to new markets: upstate New York, Texas, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Colorado. Each new location marked a victory, showcasing the brand’s rapid ascent in the competitive fast-casual dining realm.
Industry leaders recognized Papanier’s visionary leadership. In 2021, he received the title of Philadelphia CEO of the Year. He also earned the prestigious Titan100 award for three consecutive years, culminating in his induction into their Hall of Fame. These accolades underscore his impact on the business landscape.
The Papanier Philosophy: Tradition Meets Strategy
Nicholas Papanier Jr.’s leadership is a unique blend of old-world values and modern business acumen. He makes bold decisions, communicates directly, and fosters a family-like team culture. These qualities proved invaluable when the world faced unprecedented challenges. During the pandemic, Papanier’s leadership guided PrimoHoagies to a remarkable 22% revenue increase. This resilience speaks volumes about his ability to navigate difficult circumstances and turn them into opportunities for growth. Further recognition for his leadership came with the 2024 Titan 100, NJBIZ 40 Under 40, and Philadelphia Business Journal’s 40 Under 40 awards. These honors solidify his reputation as a formidable leader.
At the core of Papanier’s leadership lies a commitment to tradition and family values. These principles guide his every decision, ensuring each choice aligns with the heritage of PrimoHoagies. He learned a crucial lesson: the importance of strategic foresight and calculated decision-making. He often operates under the principle, “Never let anyone know your next move.” This blend of value-driven leadership and calculated strategy allows PrimoHoagies to stay ahead, all while remaining true to its roots.
PrimoHoagies defines leadership through an unwavering commitment to excellence. The brand sets high standards for quality, customer satisfaction, and brand values. It expects consistency across all levels, from franchisees to staff, and never compromises on its core principles. This dedication to excellence resonates throughout the entire organization.
Cultivating Connection: Building a Unified Team
Papanier understands that a strong team culture forms the backbone of any successful enterprise. PrimoHoagies prioritizes open communication and full transparency, fostering connection and unity among its franchisees and team members as it expands nationally. Regular team outings help keep everyone aligned, connected, and united as the brand grows. This focus on internal cohesion ensures that even as the company expands, it retains its close-knit identity.
PrimoHoagies strikes a careful balance between preserving its traditional brand standard and embracing modern trends. Papanier cultivates innovation, yet he remains true to the brand’s heritage. This approach allows the company to evolve without losing its distinctive character.
The Future Forward: Technology and Accessibility
Nicholas Papanier Jr. anticipates that accessibility will drive the future of fast-casual dining. To stay ahead, PrimoHoagies focuses on expanding its digital presence, enhancing social media engagement, and providing a seamless online ordering experience across all platforms. He recognizes that customer expectations have shifted towards speed, convenience, and digital connection.
PrimoHoagies enhances the customer experience through strategic technology investments. The company upgrades its app, refines its website, and builds a robust infrastructure. This ensures seamless interactions and meets customers’ evolving needs, all while maintaining high standards for quality and service. Papanier understands that technology serves as a tool to enhance the core experience, not replace it.
The PrimoHoagies Difference: Quality and Consistency
PrimoHoagies stands out in the competitive foodservice landscape due to its unwavering commitment to quality and tradition. This dedication creates a distinctive brand identity, one that resonates deeply with customers and sets it apart from the competition. It is not just a sandwich; it is an experience, a taste of a long-standing tradition.
Papanier ensures quality and consistency by implementing robust systems and check-ins at every store. The brand also fosters strong connections with franchisees through regular meetings, promoting a unified approach to delivering an exceptional customer experience. This hands-on involvement ensures that every hoagie, no matter the location, meets the PrimoHoagies standard.
Partnering for Success: Selecting the Right Franchisees
Nicholas Papanier Jr. does not seek just any franchise partners. He looks for individuals who share the same passion for quality and commit to hard work. He seeks out trusted fans of PrimoHoagies, ensuring a shared vision and dedication to delivering exceptional customer experiences. He understands that a franchisee’s genuine belief in the product translates directly to customer satisfaction.
Keeping the “Family Feel”: Community at the Core
PrimoHoagies maintains its family feel by staying true to its family-owned and operated roots. The brand builds strong ties within every community it serves, fostering a sense of connection and loyalty that transcends its national expansion. This community-centric approach ensures that even as the company grows, it remains grounded and connected to the people it serves.
PrimoHoagies prioritizes sustainability and community engagement. PrimoCares, the brand’s initiative, stands at the forefront of its efforts. Through this program, the brand gives back to the community, focusing on supporting children and building a stronger future for both the community and the brand itself. This commitment reflects Papanier’s belief that a successful business also serves a greater purpose.
A Legacy of Leadership: Fearless and Focused
Nicholas Papanier Jr. envisions a legacy of fearless leadership for PrimoHoagies and the wider food and franchise industry. He aims to set a high standard, blending bold vision with an unwavering commitment to quality, staying true to the brand’s values and traditions. This approach, he believes, will inspire others and leave a lasting impact on the industry. He is not simply building a business; he is crafting a legacy, one delicious hoagie at a time. What will he build next?
Also Read: The 10 Most Prominent Food and Beverage Leaders for 2025
